Examining the Effects of Online Shopping on Last-Mile Freight
This interview series is made possible by the Volvo Research and Educational Foundations. Each month we feature a leading thinker from VREFs Global Mobility Research program.
Meeting of the Minds talked with Dr. Alison Conway on the subject of the recent webinar, “Does Online Shopping Create Urban Congestion?” Dr. Conway will present with University of Gothenburg’s Michael Brown during the April 18th live webinar, during which she will walk us through her research on urban freight and sustainable urban logistics. Dr. Conway is Associate Professor of Civil Engineering at City College of New York and Associate Director for Education at University Transportation Research Center (UTRC). She holds a master’s degree (2005) and Ph.D. (2009) in Civil Engineering from the University of Texas at Austin. Since moving to New York in 2009, her research has focused primarily on last-mile freight issues and the challenges that occur at the delivering endpoint.
On which types of freight is your research focused?
We’re narrowing in on e-commerce and residential deliveries. Before the Internet and e-commerce existed, the traditional mode of shopping was to take your car to the retail store. The supply chain just moved goods from the warehouse to the retail store; that was their endpoint before you, the customer, came into the store to purchase them. But very quickly, over the last decade, that model has been replaced.
Now a huge amount of goods purchased online has the freight going straight to residential buildings instead of retail stores. Curb space and zoning regulations were not designed with that type of movement in mind. In New York, zoning codes haven’t been updated in 50 years. We have apartment buildings in New York with 1,000 units; if every person in those buildings is getting two packages per week, that’s 2,000 packages going to each building each week, but with no requirement for a space to be available for deliveries out front.
What are some of the last-mile freight issues you are examining in your research?
Some of the challenges include roadway infrastructure, lack of available parking, curb management, alternate modes of delivery, and interactions with non-motorized travelers. We are trying to determine how we can better accommodate freight while maintaining the benefits we’re seeing to other types of improvements to the streets, including everything from the addition of dedicated bike lanes to increased numbers of bus shelters.
How are you gathering data to understand how the increased freight traffic impacts residential areas?
We’re looking at different variables, such as how drivers behave, what’s being delivered, how often deliveries are made, whether online shopping deliveries are made at different times than traditional freight deliveries, and what kind of vehicles are being used.
At this point, no one has been able to quantify the increase in vehicle traffic due to online shopping, but we do know it’s increasing. With the growth of express deliveries, such as one- and two-hour and one- and two-day deliveries from Amazon Prime, the delivery system is even less efficient because distributers aren’t aggregating goods for one large delivery in one truck. Instead, retailers promise specific time frames for delivery, which increases vehicle traffic and reduces efficient use of those vehicles.
There is one positive aspect to this situation, which is: when delivery sizes become smaller, delivery vehicles can become smaller. With smaller delivery size, delivery bikes and even handcarts become feasible options for the last mile of delivery. As the load sizes for deliveries become smaller, it makes those green modes of transportation more competitive. If you’re delivering one small package that doesn’t require a large truck, it’s much less efficient to use a truck than a bicycle.
What are the main policy barriers to progress on freight issues?
One of the biggest challenges is the lack of awareness around the increased burden of freight traffic on residential streets. Delivery vehicles have to compete for limited available parking; their increased presence creates increased traffic congestion; and there is increased conflict with non-motorized traffic and pedestrians. There is a lack of education on this, from the general public to even the highest-level decision makers in the transit world.
Urban freight falls in an outlier, public/private space in which the public makes the decisions on when and how things move based on what options they choose for shipping, but there is no public policy on freight planning regarding when and how things move, like dedicated short-term parking spaces for delivery vehicles or set windows of time for deliveries.
Another core challenge is public perception of online shopping and the lack of awareness in terms of how this affects neighborhoods and urban traffic flow. The same person who rides a bike because they want to be green may not think twice about ordering two-hour Amazon Prime delivery, simply because they’re not aware of the issues.
How are you gathering your data, and what are your initial findings?
I literally sent students to sit curbside in front of eight residential buildings for a day to monitor everything being delivered to those buildings. This isn’t producing a significant data set, but we can characterize the significance of these movements of freight to consumers in terms of frequency of deliveries, the time it takes to make each delivery, how many deliveries are going to a single building in a single day, and the method of delivery used for the final destination – be it a freight truck, a smaller vehicle, a bicycle, or a hand cart.
The buildings we monitored were in different areas of New York City: the Bronx, Queens, Brooklyn, and Manhattan. When we looked at the vehicles being used to make deliveries to these buildings, they changed depending on the Borough. The Bronx and Queens are less densely developed, even though the buildings are a comparable size. There, trucks and step vans were used to make the deliveries. In more densely developed parts of the city we started to see a different mix of vehicles: goods were arriving by handcart from vehicles we couldn’t see, or from a local store. We also started seeing smaller vehicles being used to make those deliveries. More research needs to be done to understand the relationship, but the density of the built environment affects the way goods are moving.
How do we begin to address this issue? Is this a public policy issue?
There are multiple things that need to change to address urban freight logistics. Policy is a piece of it. The freight industry itself has been trying to develop more efficient last-mile solutions because that aspect of deliveries is very expensive for the carriers. For example, if a delivery goes out and there is no one to receive it, it has to go back to the warehouse and then back out for delivery again the next day. Now they have to deliver twice, or the customer has to go to the warehouse to pick it up. There are a lot of unhappy stakeholders in that situation.
Particularly with e-commerce, we need to see a change in the public perception in terms of understanding the consequences and downstream effects. That includes policy makers understanding the activity on the street and making potential changes to parking and land use regulation to generate more effective policies and programs.
A potential next step could be urban consolidation centers; many places in Europe have regulations on certain size trucks during certain hours, which increases the cost of operating the truck, making consolidation centers more favorable.
The freight industry is looking at solutions like delivery lockers, such as Amazon Locker, and pickup points in neighborhoods. The industry itself is trying to develop those types of solutions, so they do not need to be legislated. But there is also a policy piece in terms of curb regulation; the temporary distribution of delivery vehicle movements doesn’t follow traditional commercial trips, and they’re happening in places that didn’t plan for commercial activity on the street. Cities need more dedicated commercial space where goods can either be consolidated for last-mile delivery, or delivery vehicles have dedicated short-term parking space.
What’s in store for the future of urban freight delivery? Will drones replace street freight traffic in the coming years?
There are definitely applications for drones, but I think it’s a small piece of solution to this problem. With the density of demand right now, I’d rather see trucks on the street than envision a city sky filled with delivery drones. But in more rural environments, drones can take shorter and more direct flight paths, and therefore increase efficiency.
Leave your comment below, or reply to others.
Please note that this comment section is for thoughtful, on-topic discussions. Admin approval is required for all comments. Your comment may be edited if it contains grammatical errors. Low effort, self-promotional, or impolite comments will be deleted.
Read more from MeetingoftheMinds.org
Spotlighting innovations in urban sustainability and connected technology
Accenture analysts recently released a report calling for cities to take the lead in creating coordinated, “orchestrated” mobility ecosystems. Limiting shared services to routes that connect people with mass transit would be one way to deploy human-driven services now and to prepare for driverless service in the future. Services and schedules can be linked at the backend, and operators can, for example, automatically send more shared vehicles to a train station when the train has more passengers than usual, or tell the shared vehicles to wait for a train that is running late.
Managing urban congestion and mobility comes down to the matter of managing space. Cities are characterized by defined and restricted residential, commercial, and transportation spaces. Private autos are the most inefficient use of transportation space, and mass transit represents the most efficient use of transportation space. Getting more people out of private cars, and into shared feeder routes to and from mass transit modes is the most promising way to reduce auto traffic. Computer models show that it can be done, and we don’t need autonomous vehicles to realize the benefits of shared mobility.
The role of government, and the planning community, is perhaps to facilitate these kinds of partnerships and make it easier for serendipity to occur. While many cities mandate a portion of the development budget toward art, this will not necessarily result in an ongoing benefit to the arts community as in most cases the budget is used for public art projects versus creating opportunities for cultural programming.
Rather than relying solely on this mandate, planners might want to consider educating developers with examples and case studies about the myriad ways that artists can participate in the development process. Likewise, outreach and education for the arts community about what role they can play in projects may stimulate a dialogue that can yield great results. In this sense, the planning community can be an invaluable translator in helping all parties to discover a richer, more inspiring, common language.
While the outlook for the environment may often seem bleak, there are many proven methods already available for cities to make their energy systems and other infrastructure not only more sustainable, but cheaper and more resilient at the same time. This confluence of benefits will drive investments in clean, efficient energy, transportation, and water infrastructure that will enable cities to realize their sustainability goals.
Given that many of the policy mechanisms that impact cities’ ability to boost sustainability are implemented at the state or federal level, municipalities should look to their own operations to implement change. Cities can lead as a major market player, for example, by converting their own fleets to zero emission electric vehicles, investing in more robust and efficient water facilities, procuring clean power, and requiring municipal buildings to be LEED certified.