Heat Action Planning is Tackling Urban Heat at the Hyper-Local Level
Urban heat is a growing problem that impacts public health and the economy. In metropolitan Phoenix, the number of days above 110 degrees are projected to double by 2060. Extreme heat presents a resilience challenge in managing urban development, especially when temperatures can differ by more than 10°F between neighborhoods under certain conditions. As a result, not all populations are affected equally by the impacts of urban heat. Vulnerable populations have been identified as the elderly, children, those living in areas with little vegetation or shading, those with pre-existing health conditions, and ethnic minorities. The choices cities make about urban development, materials, and green infrastructure can make a big difference in thermal comfort ( how a population experiences heat). At the community level, there is a sense that extreme heat is too large a problem for neighborhoods to tackle, and a general resignation among residents that this is “just the way it is.”
“With conversations with neighbors, what is very interesting to me is that they say, “oh, it’s hot, that’s normal.” And I think that’s the interesting part of the conversation. It is hot, but it’s not normal. There is something that we can do.” – Community Partner
A participatory heat action planning process, Nature’s Cooling Systems, identified urban heat mitigation and adaptation strategies that focus specifically at the neighborhood scale. The framework is called the NCS Heat Action Planning Guide. The core team, consisting of The Nature Conservancy, Arizona State University, and Maricopa County Department of Health, selected three heat vulnerable communities based upon heat intensity, strong community identity, health risk factors, the presence of development projects planned or underway, and other factors. The three neighborhoods involved in heat action planning are Edison-Eastlake and Lindo-Roesley in Phoenix, and the Mesa Care neighborhood in Mesa.
Community-based organizations (CBO) in each of the three communities were brought into the project to facilitate community engagement and to provide insight into unique community identities, needs, and histories. The CBOs were a critical component in developing the heat action plans as they were responsible for recruiting workshop participants, selecting demonstration projects, and bringing in other CBOs, city decision makers, and community leaders.
A series of three workshops in each community were held in the summer of 2018. The first workshop detailed cool and hot spots within neighborhoods, highlighted assets, and provided an opportunity for the core team, CBOs, and residents to share their stories about urban heat. Storytelling was used throughout the workshops by residents, subject matter experts, decision-makers, and scientists. Using stories allowed for building trust quickly, and this facilitated an understanding of the underlying science behind the drivers and solutions for extreme heat. The local wisdom of residents in coping with heat provided insight for the core team and other participants.
“What makes this project unique is that we’re focused on improving quality of life, we’re not just recording facts about heat and shade, etc. You need people’s experiences to drive the process of change.” – Core Team Partner
The second workshop focused on providing possible strategies to address the urban heat related concerns identified in the first workshop. These ideas were refined in the third workshop. Four overarching themes emerged across all three neighborhoods:
- Advocacy and education
- Improve comfort and ability to cope
- Improve safety
- Build capacity
The central Phoenix neighborhood of Edison-Eastlake is the recipient of a $30M Housing and Urban Development Choice Neighborhood Grant to redevelop the largest concentration of public housing within the City of Phoenix. The Phoenix Revitalization Corporation (PRC), which was selected as the community-based organization for the Nature’s Cooling Systems project, developed a Resident Leadership Council to ensure that the ongoing redevelopment project has resident input. The Edison Eastlake NCS Heat Action Plan stressed shade in any form (trees, constructed, shade from built environment) along public transit routes, with drinking water available at half mile intervals, and prioritized the elderly and those with disabilities for cooling interventions. They requested assistance with the high cost of electricity for indoor cooling. Residents were interested in learning how to better handle heat emergency situations, and requested a preventative warning system and a first aid certification program specifically tailored to urban living heat exposure issues.
The Mesa Care neighborhood, also known as the Water Tower Improvement District, is located in West Mesa, Arizona, which is part of the Broadway Corridor redesign project currently underway on a major traffic corridor and community center. The CBO for this community, RAILMesa, consists of residents, artists, and local business owners leading a grassroots effort to build and advocate for a stronger, better, connected light rail corridor in Mesa. This neighborhood emphasized the need to keep children safe in the hot weather, and requested heat safety educational programs, shade along access routes to schools, and water features such as splash pads or sprinklers to cool off. The water features could also benefit vegetation with runoff, reducing tree maintenance costs.
Mesa Care residents were also concerned about their elderly residents, especially those living alone, due to their limited income and decreased mobility. Residents felt that these older community members, especially those that have lived in the neighborhood for twenty years or longer, could provide wisdom in how to cope with heat and wanted to ensure they were cared for during extreme heat days. An emergency summer plan, targeted to both children and adults, would build awareness of cool spots and official cooling centers, eliminate needless wait times at bus stops, and highlight access to drinking water. Reusable water bottles could be distributed at school with safety information on the side, so teachers would not allow any child to leave school without a full bottle of water. The safety information could be the basis for an advocacy program as well. Here is the full Mesa Care NCS Heat Action Plan.
This South Phoenix community, Lindo-Roesley Park, has a rich Latino and farming cultural identity that is being threatened by gentrification with an extension of the light rail close to the neighborhood. Puente Movement, a grassroots organization that is a leader on social justice issues, led the heat action planning in this neighborhood. Residents would like to provide more shade throughout the community by planting more trees but face barriers to maintaining them properly such as limited funds and living in rental property. They would like to see a community tree fund developed that helps maintain large mature shade trees, assists with the financial burden of removing dead trees and the purchase of replacement trees. Landowners could agree to install a “rest stop” on their property to allow neighbors to cool down and stay safe in extreme heat. A stormwater capture system could irrigate these spaces and alleviate flooding which is a common occurrence. Residents requested approaching shade, water, and access to the bus route as a system that would allow for greater thermal comfort and safety. Click here for the full Lindo Roesley Park NCS Heat Action Plan.
The Nature’s Cooling Systems project addressed inequalities and developed a plan to provide greater thermal comfort and improve public health outcomes and can serve as a model for other municipalities that wish to address urban heat at the hyper-local scale. The resident-inspired strategies for creating a cooler community were guided by evidence-based research, design principles, context-specific assets, and local adaptation behaviors. The community-based organizations, armed with scientific knowledge, the vocabulary of urban heat decision makers, and empowered residents are the leading advocates for heat action plan implementation.
Leave your comment below, or reply to others.
Please note that this comment section is for thoughtful, on-topic discussions. Admin approval is required for all comments. Your comment may be edited if it contains grammatical errors. Low effort, self-promotional, or impolite comments will be deleted.
Read more from MeetingoftheMinds.org
Spotlighting innovations in urban sustainability and connected technology
A new toolkit has been developed to help businesses think through strategies to decrease mobility barriers to the workplace, which reduces turnover. When workers can reliably get to work regardless of their personal circumstances, it provides employment stability and the opportunity to build wealth. It’s a win-win. Developed through a partnership between Metropolitan Planning Council and a pro bono Boston Consulting Group team, the toolkit includes slide decks, an overview report, customizable templates, a cost calculator, and instructional videos walking a company through the thought process of establishing a baseline situation, evaluating and selecting a solution, and standing up a program.
Depending on the employer’s location and employees’ needs, solutions may range from helping with last-mile transportation to the transit system, to developing on-demand vanpools, to establishing in-house carpool matching systems. The ROI calculator gives employers the ability to determine the break-even cost—the subsidy amount a company can manage without hurting the bottom line.
Housing that is affordable to low-income residents is often substandard and suffering from deferred maintenance, exposing residents to poor air quality and high energy bills. This situation can exacerbate asthma and other respiratory health issues, and siphon scarce dollars from higher value items like more nutritious food, health care, or education. Providing safe, decent, affordable, and healthy housing is one way to address historic inequities in community investment. Engaging with affordable housing and other types of community benefit projects is an important first step toward fully integrating equity into the green building process. In creating a framework for going deeper on equity, our new book, the Blueprint for Affordable Housing (Island Press 2020), starts with the Convention on Human Rights and the fundamental right to housing.
I caught up recently with Sarah Charlton who is Associate Professor at the School of Architecture and Planning at the University of Witwatersrand in Johannesburg.
The research she is leading, located in both Johannesburg, South Africa and Maputo, Mozambique, looks at the interface between the mobility use by residents and transportation investments by the state. The question guiding her research is “are ordinary households using the transport modes that the government is investing in and prioritizing?” The research is a partnership between two universities across two countries and two cities.
Sarah reflects on research during the pandemic across languages, countries, histories and cultures.