Addressing Housing as a Cornerstone for Community Health
Who will you meet?
Cities are innovating, companies are pivoting, and start-ups are growing. Like you, every urban practitioner has a remarkable story of insight and challenge from the past year.
Meet these peers and discuss the future of cities in the new Meeting of the Minds Executive Cohort Program. Replace boring virtual summits with facilitated, online, small-group discussions where you can make real connections with extraordinary, like-minded people.
High housing costs can make a difference in how well and how long we live. This topic is the focus of this year’s County Health Rankings, an annual report on the many factors that shape health and opportunity, county by county, across the nation. This year, data in our Key Findings Report show us that too many communities are burdened by severe housing costs—when people must spend more than half of their income to secure a place to live for themselves and their families.
This year’s findings are sobering, and they document an issue that is pervasive in counties across the country. Severe housing costs affect people of all backgrounds, but low-income families and households of color, including Black and Hispanic people—are more likely to suffer the burden and impacts of severe housing costs.
The high cost of housing affects every county in the nation, particularly urban communities. More than one in ten households live with the burden of severe housing costs. In other words, they spend more than half of what they earn on rent or mortgage payments. This is particularly true in larger urban metro counties, where the percentage of households that are housing cost burdened is higher than in smaller metro, suburban, or rural counties. In many communities, the increase in housing costs have outpaced increases in local incomes. Renters are also disproportionately burdened by high housing costs with one in four renters impacted. And low-income renters experience an even greater financial burden with one in two spending more than half their paycheck on rent.
- Renters are disproportionately burdened by high housing costs—and low-income renters experience an even greater financial burden. One in four renters spends more than half of their paycheck on housing. For low-income renters, the burden is particularly harsh, with half spending more than 50 percent of their paychecks on rent. The severe housing cost burden also disproportionately impacts Black individuals and families, who are more likely to rent than own a home.
- High housing costs prevent too many families from building wealth, especially Black families. Owning a home is an important vehicle for families to build wealth for their children and grandchildren, but not everyone has had a fair chance to pursue this valued American dream because of decades of discriminatory practices and lending policies. More than 70 percent of White households own a home compared to just over 40 percent of Black households—and this pattern of limited opportunity in homeownership holds true for other racial and ethnic groups as well.
The Connection Between Housing Cost, Health, and Discrimination
When a family must spend more than half of its paycheck on rent or the mortgage, there is little room in the budget for other essentials that contribute to good health, such as healthy food, medicine, or transportation to work and school. Across all counties, as the share of people experiencing the burden of severe housing costs increases, so does the number of children in poverty, the number of people who don’t know where their next meal will come from, and the number of people in poor or fair health
Discriminatory policies and practices such as redlining or banking practices that target people of color with subprime loans, have resulted in gaps between white communities and communities of color when it comes to education, employment, community connections and supports, and safe neighborhoods – all of which are fundamental to achieving long and healthy lives.
Communities That Are Making a Difference
High housing cost is a thorny problem, and there’s no single solution. However, there are many things that communities can consider, and several approaches to creating and preserving affordable housing to learn from.
Just north of St. Louis, Missouri, there are 24 small, contiguous municipalities formed the 24:1 Community. This group brings together organizations across municipal boundaries to address housing challenges. Governments and nonprofit organizations partner with residents to boost homeownership and build wealth. For example, two nonprofit organizations: Beyond Housing and the 24:1 Community Land Trust, work together to offer an affordable quality homes through a program that helps residents become homeowners. The program provides buyers with financial advice, connection to services after purchase, and reinvests back into the community. These efforts are helping to keep housing affordable, empower residents financially, and create healthier neighborhoods.
The community of Chelsea, Massachusetts, just outside of Boston, knows health and housing are inextricably linked. In 2018, a multi-agency organization called CONNECT helped more than 450 clients get back on their feet by stabilizing their income and/or housing. The Neighborhood Developers, a local community development corporation, was instrumental in the development of the Box District; a 248-unit development where half of the units were designated as affordable. Beyond building new homes, Chelsea is focused on the preservation, rehabilitation, and maintenance of existing affordable housing through an Affordable Housing Trust Fund.
In South Carolina, Spartanburg County’s Northside Neighborhood—a place once plagued by blight, unemployment, and poverty—is being transformed to expand affordable housing and set community residents on a path to better health. The Northside Development Group, in collaboration with community partners, is working to increase educational and recreational opportunities, and expand community services. So far, they’ve created a healthy food hub, new green spaces, and a community center.
Four Solutions for Communities to Explore
Fortunately, there are many strategies that communities can use to develop and secure more affordable housing—and ultimately realize better health—for residents, and particularly for low- to moderate-income residents.
1. Communities can become more inclusive and connected by:
- Adopting inclusionary zoning laws
- Engaging all residents, including youth, in public governance and community development decisions
- Passing and enforcing fair housing laws
- Creating housing mobility programs
- Developing mixed income communities
- Ensuring access to living wage jobs, quality health care, grocery stores, green spaces and parks, and public transportation systems in all communities
2. Facilitate access to the resources that residents – particularly low to moderate income families need to secure affordable housing, such as housing choice vouchers or housing trust funds.
3. Implement policies that provide capital resources that create and preserve affordable housing, such as:
- Acquisition, management, and financing of land for affordable housing
- Tax credits, block grants, housing trust funds, and other government subsidies or revenues to advance affordable housing development
- Zoning changes that reduce the cost of housing production
4. Provide the services that help those who struggle with safe and secure housing. These strategies could include:
- Rapid re-housing programs, supportive housing, service-enriched housing, and rental assistance
- Eviction prevention services
- Income supports, like living wage laws, paid family leave, or Earned Income Tax Credits
Our Homes, Our Communities, Our Health
Where we live—our homes and our neighborhoods—influences our health. Safe, secure, and affordable housing is a basic cornerstone of building a healthy life for ourselves and our families. And when more people in a community have access to safe, secure, and affordable homes, we all benefit. The question is, how can we work together to make this a reality for everyone in our communities?
Leave your comment below, or reply to others.
Please note that this comment section is for thoughtful, on-topic discussions. Admin approval is required for all comments. Your comment may be edited if it contains grammatical errors. Low effort, self-promotional, or impolite comments will be deleted.
Read more from MeetingoftheMinds.org
Spotlighting innovations in urban sustainability and connected technology
A few years ago, I worked with some ARISE-US members to carry out a survey of small businesses in post-Katrina New Orleans of disaster risk reduction (DRR) awareness. One theme stood out to me more than any other. The businesses that had lived through Katrina and survived well understood the need to be prepared and to have continuity plans. Those that were new since Katrina all tended to have the view that, to paraphrase, “well, government (city, state, federal…) will take care of things”.
While the experience after Katrina, of all disasters, should be enough to show anyone in the US that there are limits on what government can do, it does raise the question, of what could and should public and private sectors expect of one another?
When planning for new mobilities, it is important to be a little skeptical. Advocates often exaggerate the benefits and overlook significant costs. Here’s an example. Optimists predict that autonomous cars will reduce traffic congestion, crash risk, energy consumption and pollution emissions, but to achieve these benefits they require dedicated lanes for platooning (many vehicles driving close together at relatively high speeds). When should communities dedicate special lanes for the exclusive use of autonomous vehicles? How much should users pay for the privilege? How should this be enforced? Who will be liable if a high-speed platoon crashes, resulting in a multi-vehicle pile-up?
Infrastructure is on the tip of every mayor’s tongue. It’s no wonder, with billions in federal funding on the table for the first time in a generation and rapidly compounding infrastructure needs. American Rescue Plan dollars represent a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to invest in communities, support resident priorities, and move the needle on racial equity all at the same time. Parks and playgrounds exist in an ideal sweet spot in each of these areas, and cities should consider making investments in these vital pieces of community infrastructure as part of their recovery and resilience strategies.